Shakespeareās plays are still worth our attention
because they body forth so brilliantly the virulent
and interesting disease called Western culture.
Racism, imperial domination, anti-Semitism, sexist
craziness and the phallic code of war are not
incidental to that culture. They have been intrinsic
parts of it, and Shakespeare gives us a wonderful
map of the metaphorical system by which that
culture enforces itself. ...
I donāt mean to argue for a Shakespeare who was
a feminist, or a Marxist. Shakespeare was obviously
interested in order, hierarchy and patriarchy. But he
was also a connoisseur of disorder, civil war, family
strife, madness and rebellion. The spark of dramatic
interest always lies in his perception of ļ¬aws,
tensions and anomalies in the dominant ideology. He
exploits these cracks, expressing problems covered
over by the apparent social consensus.
Charles Sugnet
āShakespeare Without Guts,ā In Our Times, December 23, 1981 ā
January 12, 1982
The Tempest, A Midsummer Nightās Dream and
The Merry Wives of Windsor, which was written
for a command performance, are the only plays of
Shakespeare with an original pot. The Tempest is
also his only play observing the unities of time, place,
and action ā which accounts for Prosperoās long,
expository narrative at the beginning of the play
instead of action. ā¦
The Tempest ends, like the other plays in
Shakespeareās last period, in reconciliation and
forgiveness. But the ending in The Tempest is grimmer,
and the sky is darker than in The Winterās Tale,
Pericles and Cymbeline. Everybody in the earlier plays
asks forgiveness and gets it, but Prospero, Miranda,
Ferdinand, Gonzalo and Alonso are the only ones
really in the magic circle of The Tempest. Alonso is
forgiven because he asks to be. He is the least guilty,
and he suīers most. ā¦ Neither Antonio nor Sebastian
say a word to Prospero ā their only words after the
reconciliation are mockery at Trinculo, Stephano and
Caliban. Theyāre spared punishment, but they canāt
be said to be forgiven because they donāt want to
be, and Prosperoās forgiveness of them means only
that he does not take revenge upon them. Caliban is
pardoned conditionally, and he, Stephano and Trinculo
canāt be said to be repentant. They realize only that
theyāre on the wrong side, and admit they are fools,
not that they are wrong.
W. H. Auden
Lectures on Shakespeare, 2000
These readings very much depend on oneās
conception of European manās place in
the universe, and on whether a ļ¬gure like
Prospero stands for all mankind or for one
side of a conļ¬ict.
The ļ¬rst interpretation, following upon the
ideas of Renaissance humanism and the
place of the artist/playwright/magician,
oīers a story of mankind at the center
of the universe, of āmanā as creator and
authority. ā¦ Prospero has often been seen
as a ļ¬gure for the artist as creator ā as
Shakespeareās stand-in, so to speak, or
Shakespeareās self-conception, an artist
ļ¬gure unifying the world around him by his
āso potent art.ā ā¦ Prosperoās magic books
enable him as well to thwart the incipient
revolts of both high and low conspirators,
and to exact a species of revenge against
those who usurped his dukedom and set
him adrift on the sea ā for The Tempest
is one of Shakespeareās most compelling
ārevenge tragedies,ā turned, at the last
moment, toward forgiveness. ā¦
The second kind of interpretation, the
colonial or postcolonial narrative, follows
upon early modern voyages of exploration
and discovery, āļ¬rst contact,ā and the
encounters with, and exploitation of,
indigenous peoples in the New World. In
this interpretive context The Tempest is not
idealizing, aesthetic, and ātimeless,ā but
rather topical, contextual, āpolitical,ā and in
dialogue with the times. Yet manifestly this
dichotomy will break down, both in literary
analysis and in performance. It is perfectly
possible for a play about a mage, artist, and
father to be, at the same time, a play about
a colonial governor, since Prospero himself
is, or was, the Duke of Milan.
Marjorie Garber
Shakespeare After All, 2008
Shakespeareās powerful late
romance The Tempest has been
addressed by modern critics from
two important perspectives: as a
fable of art and creation, and as a
colonialist allegory.
8 \ GUTHRIE THEATER PLAY GUIDE THE TEMPEST